Major League Soccer Β· USA Β· Round 1

Columbus Crew
3 - 2 Full time
New York City FC

Columbus Crew Stadium

Lineups

Columbus Crew4-2-3-1
SC1Clark
HA25↓79'Afful
MP4Parkhurst
TW2Wahl
WF14Francis
WT20Trapp
MS8↓90'Saeid
EF13⚽Finlay
FH10↓88'Higuain
JM9⚽Meram
KA23⚽Kamara
JS12Saunders
AI51Iraola
FB13Brillant
JH2Hernandez
RM22Matarrita
MD10Diskerud
AP21Pirlo
TM15↓58'McNamara
TT99↓58'Taylor
DV7βš½Γ—2Villa
SM9↓80'Mendoza
New York City FC4-3-3

Columbus Crew substitutes

16 Hector Jimenez ↑79'
33 Amro Tarek ↑88'
19 Rodrigo Saravia ↑90'
41 Brad Stuver
11 Cedrick Mabwati
27 Conor Casey
17 Ola Kamara

Coach: Gregg Berhalter

New York City FC substitutes

19 Khiry Shelton 5.8 ↑58'
88 Kwadwo Poku 7.3 ↑58'
14 Patrick Mullins 6.0 ↑80'
30 Diego Martinez
25 Eirik Holmen Johansen
6 Federico Bravo
27 R. J. Allen

Coach: Patrick Vieira

Match events

7'Ethan Finlay assist: Justin Meram 1 - 0⚽
15'David Villa assist: Andoni Iraola 1 - 1⚽
Second half
49'Kei Ansu Kamara assist: Justin Meram 2 - 1⚽
58'↑ Khiry Shelton ↓ Tony Taylor⇄
58'↑ Kwadwo Poku ↓ Thomas McNamara⇄
79'↑ Hector Jimenez ↓ Harrison Afful⇄
80'↑ Patrick Mullins ↓ Stiven Mendoza⇄
80'Justin Meram assist: Ethan Finlay 3 - 1⚽
86'Michael Parkhurst
87'David Villa (penalty) 3 - 2⚽
88'↑ Amro Tarek ↓ Federico Higuain⇄
90'↑ Rodrigo Saravia ↓ Mohammed Saeid⇄

Where to watch Major League Soccer

USAApple TV (MLS Season Pass), FOX Sports (selected matches)
United KingdomApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
PakistanApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
IndiaApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
CanadaApple TV (MLS Season Pass), TSN (selected matches)
AustraliaApple TV (MLS Season Pass)

Official broadcasters for the 2026-27 season. Rights can change during the season β€” always confirm with the broadcaster before subscribing.

Match details

CompetitionMajor League Soccer
Kick-off (UTC)Saturday, 16 April 2016, 23:35 UTC β€” shown in your local time at the top of this page
StatusFinished

Line-ups, match events and the head-to-head record for this fixture are shown on this page where the data feed publishes them.

Head to head

1Columbus Crew wins1Draws0New York City FC wins

2 past meetings on record. Biggest New York City FC win: New York City FC 1–2 Columbus Crew (2015).

29 Aug 2015New York City FC 1 - 2 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
20 Aug 2015Columbus Crew 2 - 2 New York City FCMajor League Soccer