Major League Soccer · USA · Round 1

Columbus Crew
2 - 2 Full time
New York City FC

MAPFRE Stadium · Columbus, Ohio

Lineups

Columbus Crew4-2-3-1
ZS23Steffen
JW3↓76'Williams
JM4Mensah
GS22Sauro
HJ16Jimenez
WT6Trapp
DG9↓83'Guzmán
R18↓63'Robinho
PS7âš½Santos
DA29Accam
GZ11âš½Zardes
SJ1Johnson
MC4Chanot
JS16Sands
AC6Callens
AT3Tinnerholm
AR8Ring
EO12↓67'Ofori
BS2↓45'Sweat
MM10Moralez
H9âš½Heber
AM28↓89'Mitrita
New York City FC3-4-3

Columbus Crew substitutes

2 Luis Argudo 5.3 ↑63'
31 Connor Maloney 6.4 ↑76'
8 Artur ↑83'
21 Alex Crognale
24 Jon Kempin
32 Patrick Mullins
13 Ricardo A. Clark

Coach: Caleb Porter

New York City FC substitutes

29 Ismael Tajouri-Shradi 6.5 ↑45'
11 Valentin Castellanos 7.4 ⚽↑67'
15 Tony Rocha ↑89'
41 Brad Stuver
14 Juan Torres
22 Ronald Matarrita
33 Sebastien Ibeagha

Coach: Domenec Torrent

Match events

14'Maxi Moralez
28'Gyasi Zardes (penalty) 1 - 0âš½
34'David Guzmán
45'↑ Ismael Tajouri-Shradi ↓ Ben Sweat⇄
Second half
57'Heber assist: Maxi Moralez 1 - 1âš½
61'Pedro Santos assist: David Accam 2 - 1âš½
63'↑ Luis Argudo ↓ Robinho⇄
67'↑ Valentin Castellanos ↓ Ebenezer Ofori⇄
72'Gaston Sauro
76'↑ Connor Maloney ↓ Josh Williams⇄
76'Valentin Castellanos assist: Alexander Ring 2 - 2âš½
83'↑ Artur ↓ David Guzmán⇄
85'Valentin Castellanos
89'↑ Tony Rocha ↓ Alexandru Mitrita⇄
90'Jonathan Mensah

Where to watch Major League Soccer

USAApple TV (MLS Season Pass), FOX Sports (selected matches)
United KingdomApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
PakistanApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
IndiaApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
CanadaApple TV (MLS Season Pass), TSN (selected matches)
AustraliaApple TV (MLS Season Pass)

Official broadcasters for the 2026-27 season. Rights can change during the season — always confirm with the broadcaster before subscribing.

Match details

CompetitionMajor League Soccer
Kick-off (UTC)Saturday, 1 June 2019, 23:40 UTC — shown in your local time at the top of this page
StatusFinished

Line-ups, match events and the head-to-head record for this fixture are shown on this page where the data feed publishes them.

Head to head

4Columbus Crew wins4Draws4New York City FC wins

11 past meetings on record. Biggest Columbus Crew win: Columbus Crew 4–1 New York City FC (2017). Biggest New York City FC win: Columbus Crew 2–3 New York City FC (2017).

2 Sep 2018Columbus Crew 2 - 1 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
15 Jul 2018New York City FC 2 - 0 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
5 Nov 2017New York City FC 2 - 0 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer Playoff
1 Nov 2017Columbus Crew 4 - 1 New York City FCMajor League Soccer Playoff
22 Oct 2017New York City FC 2 - 2 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
30 Apr 2017Columbus Crew 2 - 3 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
23 Oct 2016New York City FC 4 - 1 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
14 Aug 2016Columbus Crew 3 - 3 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
17 Apr 2016Columbus Crew 3 - 2 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
29 Aug 2015New York City FC 1 - 2 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
Show all 11 past meetings
20 Aug 2015Columbus Crew 2 - 2 New York City FCMajor League Soccer