Major League Soccer · USA · Round 1

Columbus Crew
4 - 2 Full time
New York City FC

Lower.com Field · Columbus, Ohio

Lineups

Columbus Crew3-4-2-1
PS28Schulte
SM31Moreira
RC4Camacho
MA18↓71'Amundsen
MF23↓90'Farsi
MA27⚽↓90'Arfsten
SZ25↓90'Zawadzki
DN6Nagbe
CR17↓71'Ramirez
DR10⚽Rossi
JH9↓90'Hernández
MF49↓12'Freese
TG24Gray
TM13Martins
BR5Risa
KO22↓61'O'Toole
JS6↓45'Sands
KP55Parks
HW17↓73'Wolf
SR10Rodriguez
AO26↓60'Ojeda
AM16⚽↓60'Martinez
New York City FC4-2-3-1

Columbus Crew substitutes

21 Evgen Cheberko 6.2 ↑71'
20 Alexandru Matan 7.5 ↑71'
12 DeJuan Jones ⚽↑90'
14 Yaw Yeboah ↑90'
19 Jacen Russell-Rowe ⚽↑90'
7 Dylan Chambost ↑90'
22 Abraham Romero
13 Aziel Jackson
5 Derrick Jones

Coach: Wilfried Nancy · Unavailable: Nicholas Hagen (injury)

New York City FC substitutes

1 Luis Barraza 4.6 ↑12'
80 Justin Haak 6.3 ↑45'
27 Maxi Moralez 6.5 ↑60'
9 Monsef Bakrar 7.3 ⚽↑60'
18 Christian McFarlane 6.9 ↑61'
11 Julian Fernandez 4.8 ↑73'
35 Mitja Ilenic
12 Strahinja Tanasijevic
7 Jovan Mijatovic

Coach: Nick Cushing · Unavailable: Malachi Jones (injury)

Match events

4'Alonso Martinez assist: Tayvon Gray 0 - 1⚽
12'↑ Luis Barraza ↓ Matt Freese⇄
17'Diego Rossi assist: Christian Ramirez 1 - 1⚽
21'Malte Amundsen
45+6'↑ Justin Haak ↓ James Sands⇄
Second half
58'Max Arfsten assist: Diego Rossi 2 - 1⚽
60'↑ Monsef Bakrar ↓ Alonso Martinez⇄
60'↑ Maxi Moralez ↓ Agustin Ojeda⇄
61'↑ Christian McFarlane ↓ Kevin O'Toole⇄
71'↑ Evgen Cheberko ↓ Malte Amundsen⇄
71'↑ Alexandru Matan ↓ Christian Ramirez⇄
72'Maxi Moralez
73'↑ Julian Fernandez ↓ Hannes Wolf⇄
85'Santiago Rodriguez
86'Monsef Bakrar 2 - 2⚽
90'↑ DeJuan Jones ↓ Mohamed Farsi⇄
90'↑ Yaw Yeboah ↓ Max Arfsten⇄
90'↑ Jacen Russell-Rowe ↓ Sean Zawadzki⇄
90+3'DeJuan Jones assist: Alexandru Matan 3 - 2⚽
90+5'Julian Fernandez
90+6'↑ Dylan Chambost ↓ Juan Hernández⇄
90+10'Jacen Russell-Rowe 4 - 2⚽

Where to watch Major League Soccer

USAApple TV (MLS Season Pass), FOX Sports (selected matches)
United KingdomApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
PakistanApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
IndiaApple TV (MLS Season Pass)
CanadaApple TV (MLS Season Pass), TSN (selected matches)
AustraliaApple TV (MLS Season Pass)

Official broadcasters for the 2026-27 season. Rights can change during the season — always confirm with the broadcaster before subscribing.

Match details

CompetitionMajor League Soccer
Kick-off (UTC)Saturday, 31 August 2024, 23:30 UTC — shown in your local time at the top of this page
StatusFinished

Line-ups, match events and the head-to-head record for this fixture are shown on this page where the data feed publishes them.

Head to head

10Columbus Crew wins8Draws8New York City FC wins

26 past meetings on record. Biggest Columbus Crew win: New York City FC 4–1 Columbus Crew (2021). Biggest New York City FC win: New York City FC 2–3 Columbus Crew (2024).

22 Mar 2025Columbus Crew 0 - 0 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
17 Aug 2024Columbus Crew 1 - 1 New York City FCLeagues Cup Final Stage
15 Jun 2024New York City FC 2 - 3 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
9 Jul 2023Columbus Crew 1 - 1 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
17 Jun 2023New York City FC 1 - 1 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
7 Aug 2022Columbus Crew 3 - 2 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
15 May 2022New York City FC 2 - 0 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
31 Jul 2021New York City FC 4 - 1 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
18 Jul 2021Columbus Crew 2 - 1 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
23 May 2021New York City FC 1 - 2 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
Show all 26 past meetings
18 Oct 2020Columbus Crew 3 - 1 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
25 Aug 2020New York City FC 1 - 0 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
1 Mar 2020Columbus Crew 1 - 0 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
22 Aug 2019New York City FC 1 - 0 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
2 Jun 2019Columbus Crew 2 - 2 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
2 Sep 2018Columbus Crew 2 - 1 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
15 Jul 2018New York City FC 2 - 0 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
5 Nov 2017New York City FC 2 - 0 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer Playoff
1 Nov 2017Columbus Crew 4 - 1 New York City FCMajor League Soccer Playoff
22 Oct 2017New York City FC 2 - 2 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
30 Apr 2017Columbus Crew 2 - 3 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
23 Oct 2016New York City FC 4 - 1 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
14 Aug 2016Columbus Crew 3 - 3 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
17 Apr 2016Columbus Crew 3 - 2 New York City FCMajor League Soccer
29 Aug 2015New York City FC 1 - 2 Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
20 Aug 2015Columbus Crew 2 - 2 New York City FCMajor League Soccer